Novelist Joseph Shearing specialized in using real cases which took place in Victorian England, altering them for fictional purposes. MOSS ROSE in 1947 was the first film to be made from his novels, then in 1948 two of his works were adapted for the screen, this film and THE MARK OF CAIN. The movie stars Todd as a recently widowed missionary returning to her home in England from Jamaica. During the voyage, she meets Milland, a charming though dangerous rascal who is wanted by police in connection with some unsavory dealings. Milland contracts malaria while onboard the ship and Todd nurses him back to health. In London, Todd settles into her home, taking in boarders to make ends meet. Milland arrives, moves in, and proclaims his love for her. Todd is thrilled, but it seems rather obvious that Milland is only toying with her. Milland finds some letters written to her by her friend, Fitzgerald, in which Fitzgerald reveals some of her sexual indiscretions. Since Fitzgerald is now married to the wealthy Huntley, Milland believes he can use the letters to blackmail Fitzgerald. Todd's love for Milland is so great that she goes along with the plan. Huntley, however, learns of the scheme and also uncovers details of Milland's shady past. Fearing for her lover's safety, Todd poisons Huntley, then remains silent when Fitzgerald is arrested for the murder. Milland has by now genuinely fallen in love with Todd and the two make plans to leave England. Before they can depart, one of Milland's former lovers shows up and Todd, in a jealous rage, kills Milland, then turns herself into the police.
This is an intriguing film, although a little on the talky side. The performances are excellent throughout, with Milland shining as the cad, the type of role in which he excelled. Though he spent most of his time making films in the US, he occasionally returned to his native England for a production and this was his first British film since FRENCH WITHOUT TEARS in 1939. Director Allen was also an Englishman who chose to work in the US, this being his first directorial effort in his homeland. This was the fourth and last time Milland and Allen would work together, their pairing having begun in 1944 with the wonderfully eerie THE UNINVITED.
当按下五星键的那刻
…警惕某些怼大特写还缓慢变焦拉近且人物还大声呼喊的电影，最后一通闪回其实也是对观众的不够信任。仅是提出了一个话题而已，非要弄得这么苦大仇深，说得太多，音乐太响，总结太明，就不是什么真正所谓的文人电影。
聋哑的父母去看女儿的演唱和面试，实在绷不住。
抱在一起的冰风暴。
法版老师教呼吸法时手放她身上,我就在想美版估计没这种肢体接触~。
《健听女孩》是翻拍电影，原作是法国电影《贝利叶一家》，剧情人设基本沿袭了原作，细腻真诚纯净感人。照顾家人和自我发展，青涩懵懂的暗恋初恋，清纯悦耳的歌声音乐，温馨美好的捕鱼人家，在疲惫烦躁的世界，唯有音乐和真情可以慰藉。
#金帧9th#HOME4th 20220228
感人细腻，拿Best Picture也说得过去，毕竟政治极度正确。除了少数族裔和LGBTQ，还有残疾人群。从家人看正常听众神态时突然静音让我们感同身受，再到伯克利考试时手语演绎出歌词，两处音乐演唱的桥段设计相当巧妙。
不仅仅是聋哑家人对唯一健听者的依赖，也包括妹妹对家人的保护，如何放手大概是爱这件事里最难却也必须去做的事
家庭终于不再是青春片中的背景板了，无声处理那段很感人
为学校那段无声的聆听，及考场那段带手语的双重语言歌唱，加一星
情感上没有太感动，但是电影本身做得很好了，对残障人士的描绘以及这一家人的刻画很棒。靠明灭的灯来充当闹钟，家人因听不见所以会造成很多噪音，母亲甚至希望女儿也是个聋哑，这样的细节才是这部电影的灵魂。
和《犬之力》相比优点是通俗和幽默，整体还是好看的，充满青春气息，对特殊群体的关怀，虽然改编法版《贝丽叶一家》，但是剧本改编质量实属上乘，女主健听家庭的乐观与遭遇令人动容，合唱团表演的静默段落和父亲摸女儿声带听歌堪称名场面，静默的声音当观众瞬间代入了聋哑人的处境，此前一切这个家庭收到的困难处境仿佛都降临在观众身上。
李濬益不知道是否钟爱儒家文化第一韩国人，从《思悼》再到这部《兹山鱼谱》，都是浑然天成的文化。 再次借由人与自然讲超脱现实的故事。黑白色调撑起了视觉享受，浑浊社会亦难清者自清，做官者不识字，贱民者吞云吐雾。饱读圣贤诗书参摸不悟，贱民者扎根思想大地。 平行理想的堆叠碰撞，一个想认鱼，一个想读书。理想与现实悖论，师徒的摩擦，亦师亦友，从不愿和解到慢慢理解，最后归于天然一物的情怀。把中国的春秋百家争鸣的思想再次现实化，可悲中国把文化停滞于前，韩国却拿来拍给自己看。可能不是说他们偷我们的，而是我们真的不愿拍正历史了。 就如反驳现在的读书无用论一般，贱民不能参加科举买官做官为什么还要读书？ 昌大给了我们答案:"读书是为了让自己活的像个样子。"
我求求奥师傅别念了
You are all I need to get by.
原版里可爱的妈妈给毁了,原版励志的爸爸变平庸了他身上的好分了一半给哥哥,原版超抢戏的老师这里也一点不出彩，小男友比原版爱她多一些,但就...不咋重要呢，亲情戏基本毁了,爱情戏也莫名其妙,没个铺垫关键时刻小男生忽然就不唱了,妹子内心也毫无波澜~。
歌选的不行，不行法版那么有情感渲染力，比如la maladie damour，听名字就是那么美~包括Audition时的歌也不行，法版的je vole简直太好听太有感觉了
被音乐老师感动到了，真是一个负责人且会教的好老师。。。
唯一值得注意的就是聋哑家庭的设定，让人稍微了解下他们的生活，可惜还是流于形式。小学时，院里的邻居就是一对聋哑夫妇，一起住了好几年，那时也不觉得奇怪，现在回想，算是难得的经历，聋哑人不算少，但自这对夫妻之后，我似乎再也没见过这类人，也不会想关注他们的生活。
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
